Engine Problems That Seem Like Transmission Problems

By Mister Transmission

If there is one thing all drivers share in common, it is the feeling of dread we get when we hear an unfamiliar sound coming from our car. That, and of course our dislike for getting stuck in traffic. Your car can give you signs that there is something wrong from obvious alerts such as an engine light to strange sounds, smells, vibrations or grindings. The problem for most drivers is trying to figure out what is causing the issue. There can be many signs that might seem like there is something wrong with your transmission when in fact it is your engine at the root of the problem. Here are a few ways to identify engine problems over transmission problems.

Check Engine Light

This may seem a little counter-intuitive, but many drivers who know their cars to some extent may be familiar with the fact that their check engine light is often related to transmission trouble. Some drivers will choose to ignore it because they have rushed to the auto shop only to find out it is something silly, like a loose gas cap. Regardless of what is triggering your check engine light, you probably want to take its cue and bring it in for a diagnostic. If you are lucky, it is something simple. Just keep in mind the longer you wait the worse it can get. In order to diagnose it properly, we recommend you take it to a transmission specialist like Mister Transmission.

Burning Smell

There are a dozen things that can cause a burning smell in your car, including transmission problems. Many people who have experienced a burning smell due to a lack of transmission fluid may just assume this is what is causing the problem and you may just make a note to yourself to check the levels at some point. However your engine can also have issues that cause a burning smell usually related to oil leaks. You can check for signs for oil leaks such as a loose oil filter, a loose or damaged oil plug or a damaged oil gasket. Many of these issues can occur following an oil change even if it was done by a mechanic. Transmission fluid tends to have a sweeter smell, but will smell distinctly “burnt” if there is an issue. Leaks from other fluids may cause a burning smell if they leak into or onto the engine.

Hesitation

Your car hesitating when you accelerate is an issue that can be caused by transmission problems. It is possible for you to mistakenly think your gears are slipping when in fact it is your engine hesitating. It is also common to experience issues when switching from park to drive for transmission problems. When it is the engine, you will really feel it if you try to accelerate as you are getting onto the highway or trying to pass someone. Some common causes for engine hesitation are blocked air and fuel filters.

Strange Sounds

Strange sounds are often mistaken for transmission problems. There is a way to tell the difference between engine and transmission related sounds. Transmission problems result in more of a whining, humming or clunking noise. Engine troubles will be more along the lines of whirring, hissing or backfires. Your engine may also make a popping sound when hesitating.

When you are straining to figure out what the heck the sound might be, the sound may stop which can be a big relief. However if it comes and goes it can be frustrating if you are trying to pinpoint where the sound is coming from. In the case of the whining, humming and clunking caused by transmission problems it tends to last whereas popping and backfires will happen only momentarily and whirring from the engine will occur as you speed up.

As you can see learning to identify issues with your car is tricky. However it might be a little easier to determine if it is the engine or transmission problems using these indicators.

image-reviews image-reviews
Customer Reviews
Lorenzo and his team did...
Fernando Munoz
Lorenzo and his team did a great job on my VW Cabriolet. Lorenzo is very knowledgeable and provides an honest opinion. Repair had a fair cost, and I had a friendly service. I'm so pleased about finding a great transmission shop and shop crew.
Date: November 4, 2024
Website: Google
My sincere thanks to the...
Patricia Pike
My sincere thanks to the team at the Beechville Mr. Transmission. They spent the time to clearly explain what they were going to do and when it turned out that my transmission was unrepairable, they didn't charge for the time they had taken to look at it. They were very helpful and provided me with advice on next steps. Thanks guys. - Patti
Date: November 4, 2024
Website: Google
Thanks Phil for the great...
Dan Zybert
Thanks Phil for the great service you guys did for me fast transmission service with great warranty and prices.
Date: November 4, 2024
Website: Google
Casey and all the people...
Kaitlin Farmer
Casey and all the people there were so kind and helpful ! We really appreciate their service! We love how Casey would update us often. And the work that was done on our Dodge Journey was great. Highly recommend going here! Thanks Mister Transmission for all your great work !!
Date: November 2, 2024
Website: Google
Mister Transmission has always been...
Sunny L.
Mister Transmission has always been our first choice for vehicle repairs. They take the time to thoroughly check everything and, incredibly, they don’t charge any diagnostic fees. This is a huge relief, as other shops often charge hundreds just to diagnose an issue, even when they don’t fix it. Mister Transmission’s commitment to transparency and customer care makes them stand out. We trust them completely with our vehicles and highly recommend their service to anyone looking for reliable, honest auto repair.
Date: November 1, 2024
Website: Google
I had the best experience...
Tanya Comrie
I had the best experience with Mister Transmission at the Queensway. Uli took really good care of me and was very professional, kind and courteous. He was able to explain thoroughly what was the problem and gave me constant updates in terms of what was happening with my car. He took a hopeless situation with my car’s transmission (as stated by dealership) and fixed my car. It runs as good as new. John, the mechanic was very thorough as well. If you need your transmission done, please go to this location. As mentioned in another post, the owner and everyone at Mister Transmission are very honest and do a fantastic job. I cannot say enough good things about this place. Thanks Uli!
Date: November 1, 2024
Website: Google
Great service
Alan Fraser
Great service
Date: November 1, 2024
Website: Google
I recently had my transmission...
Nate Wilson
I recently had my transmission give out on my Nissan Rogue, I brought the car in and was explained the process, the price was fair and the work was done professionally. I was even able to get my brakes and exhaust repair at the same time. This shop offers it all for me, make sure to talk to Noah in the front for all your needs.
Date: October 31, 2024
Website: Google
Thank you Jordan and the...
Omar
Thank you Jordan and the amazing team. 1st class service.
Date: October 31, 2024
Website: Google
Thank you Jordan and the...
Omar
Thank you Jordan and the amazing team. 1st class service.
Date: October 31, 2024
Website: Google
Featured Services
Transmission Repair

The evolution of transmissions has made these machines and systems increasingly complex. When transmission repairs are required, determining the cause and cure for what ails can be tricky.

Read More
Transmission Technology

At Mister Transmission we have access to leading-edge diagnostic equipment, enabling us to offer you the fastest and most accurate findings about what’s going on inside your vehicle’s transmission.

Read More
Transmission Maintenance & Service

Just as you have other parts of your car serviced, your transmission needs maintenance to ensure a long life and avoid transmission problems.

Read More
Mister Transmission Blogs
Recent Blogs
Tips For Maintaining A Healthy Transmiss...
Maintaining a healthy transmission is crucial for the overall performance and
Read More
September 27, 2024
Top Reasons For Transmission Failure
Transmission issues can be a major concern for vehicle owners, leading to costly
Read More
September 20, 2024
What Happens If You Ignore Transmission ...
Ignoring transmission problems can lead to a series of escalating issues, potentially
Read More
September 13, 2024
How To Identify A Failing Transmission
Understanding when your transmission is beginning to fail can save you time, money,
Read More
September 6, 2024
The Lifespan Of A Repaired Transmission
Maintaining the health of your vehicle's transmission is crucial for its overall
Read More
August 28, 2024
Why Transmission Repairs Can Be Expensiv...
Transmission repairs are one of the most significant automotive expenses a vehicle
Read More
August 21, 2024
Can Driving With A Bad Transmission Dama...
Driving with a malfunctioning transmission can cause serious damage to your vehicle.
Read More
August 14, 2024
The Costs Of Transmission Repairs: What ...
Transmission repairs can be a significant financial burden for car owners.
Read More
August 9, 2024
Should You Repair Or Replace Your Transm...
When faced with transmission problems, many car owners grapple with the decision of
Read More
July 31, 2024
How Long Does A Transmission Repair Take...
Transmission repair is a critical aspect of vehicle maintenance that ensures your car
Read More
July 23, 2024