Transmission Problems and What To Do About Them

By Mister Transmission

Save money on transmission service with an early diagnosis and quick corrective action

Modern manual and automatic transmissions are complex machines. With that intricacy comes the possibility for a number of transmission problems to arise over time. When faced with these issues, the average driver doesn’t necessarily know what kind of problem is occurring – they just know something is wrong with their vehicle. Unfortunately, most people tend to wait far too long to book a transmission system inspection, putting it off until the problem turns into something they have to deal with. By the time these drivers finally take action, minor issues have already morphed into major expenses.

When it comes to keeping your transmission in shape, early diagnosis is key, and knowledge is power. To help drivers stay safe and control the costs of transmission system maintenance, repair, and part replacements, today’s post spotlights some of the most common transmission problems reported by our customers, then explains how to fix them without breaking the bank.

Read on to learn some of the more common transmission problems your vehicle may experience on the road, or contact your local Mister Transmission to book a free road test and multicheckand get a same-day quote on any required services.

What are the most common transmission system problems?

Table 1: Search queries for www.mistertransmission.com relating to common transmission problems in the last 90 days.

Looking into the searches we receive for our website, most queries related to common transmission problems pertain to issues such as burning smell and overheating, delayed engagement, fluid leaks, and transmission noises.

Some of these transmission problems are easily resolved at home, while others require professional skills, tools, and experience, and it’s important to recognize the difference. To that end, knowledge is power, so let us empower you with some straightforward transmission troubleshooting.

Troubleshooting common transmission problems

1.  Burning smell

Is there a burning smell in your car when you drive? That thick, acrid odour may be an indication that you’re riding the clutch; in other words, you’re needlessly keeping the clutch partially engaged, which can cause considerable damage.

That said, in some cases, burning smells indicate your transmission is likely overheating because it is low in fluid, or the transmission fluid is aerating and needs replacing.

Like any of your vehicle’s fluids, transmission fluid becomes less effective over time when it aerates (i.e. combines with oxygen), begins to thicken as a result of debris, and breaks down. It may also signal your vehicle is running low on engine oil, has an electrical short, or one of the brake pads is dragging.

Whatever the case may be, you’ll need to act fast to prevent serious transmission damages, and our technicians are standing by to help.

2.  Transmission fluid leaks

 If you find a puddle of reddish fluid pooling beneath your car where you parked, it’s quite likely one of the gaskets or seals in your transmission has sprung a leak. Rubber seals, gaskets, and o-rings wear out over time and need replacing.

A transmission has the possibility of leaking in several areas:

  • Axles seals
  • Front seal of the transmission
  • Vent (if transmission overheats)
  • Pan gaskets
  • Shifter seals or any other misc. seals

If you suspect you have a leak in your transmission, don’t wait to do something about it. Continuing to drive while your transmission fluid is leaking may cause irreparable damage to the unit, which can cost you a lot in part replacements, and even put you in serious danger on the road. If there isn’t enough fluid to keep the intricate network of your transmission’s components from fusing together due to extreme heat, you’re courting the possibility of a full mechanical breakdown.

The moment you spot a leak, book a free multi check from an experienced specialist. They will likely need to drop the transmission pan, drain the fluid, replace the filter, and then determine the precise location of the leak. In general, anytime a transmission-related problem crops up it’s wise to have the quality and quantity of your transmission fluid inspected.

Other common transmission fluid issues include:

Failing to flush your fluid

Even though most modern transmissions are now manufactured as “sealed” units, the fluid within them should still be recycled or flushed to ensure the best possible performance.

There are different opinions as to how often this should happen, but in general, it depends on how often and how far you drive your vehicle. It’s recommended to make sure the transmission fluid is serviced once every 45,000 km, to keep all the parts moving the way they should. Although transmissions are made to withstand high operating temperatures, regularly scheduled transmission fluid services can help to prolong the longevity of them and their myriad of internal parts.

Modern transmissions are built to operate without a lot of maintenance, yet they are still intricate, sensitive systems and they can break down. Our expert recommendation is to make sure you freshen up the fluid consistently.

Incorrect transmission fluid levels

When inspecting the transmission fluid, ensure it is at the correct level as described in your vehicle’s owner’s manual. Incorrect fluid levels make it impossible to create the right amount of pressure to engage the gears correctly, and may even lead to a catastrophic mechanical failure.

While insufficient transmission fluid is a major cause for concern, it is also possible to have too much of a good thing. If you own a vehicle that allows you to change the transmission fluid yourself, be careful not to overfill it. Too much transmission fluid can cause gears to slip, or potentially add pressure to seals, causing them to rupture and leak.

Keep in mind that the transmission operates based on the right amount of fluid pressure between the components. Offsetting that balance by having too much fluid in the unit could damage components or cause some components not to function properly.

1.  Delayed Engagement

You hop into your car, turn the ignition key, shift to ‘Drive’ or ‘Reverse’, and there is a seemingly long delay before the transmission engages. Known as delayed engagement, it is one of the most common symptoms of problems with any automatic transmission. A delayed engagement is a type of slip that occurs when the clutches or bands, which allow the vehicle to move, do not operate instantly. Often, this occurs when the internal seals wear or become hard from infrequent fluid replacement.

Delayed engagement is characterized by a long delay (approx. 1.5 to 2 seconds) from the moment you make your gear selection (D or R), to the moment you feel the transmission engage. You’d notice this on your first drive in the morning, if your car were parked overnight. Delayed engagement could be due to a variety of reasons from something as minor as a low level of transmission fluid, infrequent fluid replacement, or a more serious issue like failing transmission solenoids.

Transmission solenoid failure

Also called a “shift solenoid”, in automatic transmissions, the solenoid is used to regulate the flow of transmission fluid. If the solenoid is malfunctioning, it can impact how the transmission fluid is distributed while you’re shifting gears, causing delayed engagement. Solenoids can fail because of an electrical or mechanical malfunction. Because modern vehicles are heavily dependent on computers to manage the distribution and flow of fluids, these solenoids are integral to a transmission’s operation.

Inability to shift gears

In some cases, specific gears may simply refuse to engage. For example, if your vehicle is only able to shift to “Drive” and not “Reverse” successfully, then there could be a problem with the valve body.

The valve body acts as the nerve centre of the automatic transmission. It manages the flow of fluid through to the appropriate valve, which in turn, signals the respective clutch pack to engage.

How to treat delayed engagement problems

If you feel there is a lag between when you shift into gear and when the gear engages, you need to take note and monitor the problem — it could be symptomatic of something more severe. If you suspect your transmission has delayed engagement, we recommend you:

  • Avoid revving the engine when delayed engagement occurs. Increased engine speed produces friction and can damage the clutches and bands.
  • Allow time for the transmission to engage to prevent needless damage.
  • Check the fluid level. Consult your owner’s manual for correct filling and checking procedure as this varies among auto manufacturers.

For peace of mind, pinpoint diagnosis of any problems, and the best chance of minimizing your service costs, get in touch with our transmission specialists to book a free road test and multicheck.

4. Transmission noises

Another problem commonly found in transmissions is the noises they make, whether in neutral or when shifting while driving. In most cases, the issue is sourced from a lack of lubricant between the moving parts, and these noises are always a clear indication it’s time to book a multicheck or repair service.

Noises While in Neutral

Clattering, clunking, clanging, or clinking, these are some sounds you never want to hear when your vehicle is idling while parked or in neutral. More often than not, these disconcerting noises are warning signs that your transmission may be on the cusp of failing. And if you hear a constant whining sound while driving that changes pitch, or a constant tone while in neutral, it’s possible your torque converter needs inspection and repair. Other noises can be silenced by a transmission fluid service and change.

In any event, unlike other sounds a vehicle can make, transmission noises are usually constant regardless of the type of transmission that is in your car.

Noises When Shifting

Hearing a cacophony of banging, growling, buzzing, and grinding while you’re driving or shifting gears can be an even more disturbing experience. If your transmission makes troubling noises when in neutral, that’s not a good sign. To hear loud whining or other noises while you’re driving is a serious warning sign you will have a transmission failure somewhere down the road. The longer you wait to have it inspected, the greater the risk you run of a roadside breakdown.

The Role of the Computer in Pinpointing Transmission Problems

Modern vehicles are primarily computer-controlled. You’d think that would make transmission problems easier to identify, however, this is not always the case. Because the modern vehicle merges computer, mechanical, and hydraulic systems, we can’t assume that a computer error code is telling us the whole story about what is wrong with a vehicle’s transmission, even when we use the best diagnostic tools and software available.

Error codes could help to narrow down the problem, but they may indicate trouble elsewhere that can only be identified by taking a closer look. Unfortunately, this sometimes means taking things apart, and this can be a laborious and time-intensive process—it’s kind of like surgery for your vehicle. Fortunately, finding a qualified transmission surgeon has never been easier, and with 56 different locations across the country, help is closer than you think!

Preventative Maintenance: Your Transmission’s Best Defence

Every motorist should be aware of the aforementioned common signs of transmission trouble, as failing to address the warning signs such as burning smell, leaking fluids, delayed engagement and noise issues, can lead to your car breaking down.

While no automobile or mechanical or electrical device will function flawlessly forever, you can avoid many transmission problems by regularly scheduling preventative maintenance with an experienced, certified professional technician. And the more often you schedule preventative maintenance, the greater your odds of early detection and service savings.

Whatever you need to keep your transmission in shape, Mister Transmission is here to help. We offer a complete suite of transmission repair, maintenance, and part replacement services, flexible payment plans, and one of Canada’s best warranties.

To get a free quote on transmission system services from a Mister Transmission near you, you can:

image-reviews image-reviews
Customer Reviews
I'm Paul's neighbor and a...
Darryl Dalkeith
I'm Paul's neighbor and a review written about him washing the absorbant down the sewage drain is completely false. I saw him do the clean up of his driveway that got soaked with oil from working on his truck, after he soaked up the oil he shoveled the excess absorbant into the back of his truck then washed the remainder down to the end of this driveway and shoveled that into the back of his truck the only bit that went down the sewer was the dust that could not be shoveled up. It was a completely good professional job he did cleaning up the mess made..I enclosed a picture of the absorbant both wet and dry in the back of his truck to prove this point... read less
Date: September 2, 2024
Website: Google
Best place in town to...
Gushue's Landscaping
Best place in town to have any vehicle serviced and repaired. Honest, dependable and reliable service. Highly recommended.
Date: September 1, 2024
Website: Google
Brought my Honda Fit in...
Matthew Noonan
Brought my Honda Fit in for a clutch replacement, and they got it done quickly. Brian and Allen were both super helpful in the process.
Date: September 1, 2024
Website: Google
Mr. Transmission took my vehicle...
Larry Tetreault
Mr. Transmission took my vehicle in. Had a small leak. New exactly what they were doing. Did the job and did it well?
Date: September 1, 2024
Website: Google
Extremely kind and accommodating service...
Daniel Reichert
Extremely kind and accommodating service Always great experience at this Mr. Transmission
Date: August 31, 2024
Website: Google
This is one of the...
Natasha “Natasha”
This is one of the few repair shops I feel comfortable going to as a person who understands very little about cars. The people at the shop are friendly, they clearly explain your options, they do not charge you simply because they can, and are very fair. They also have a cute dog that is super friendly and helps to relieve stress.
Date: August 31, 2024
Website: Google
Giving a 4 for their...
Dazzler
Giving a 4 for their pleasant service. Nice people to deal with. Was surprised with an appointment it took 9 days to get my car back with 14 hours labour noted, but runs well so happy I'm running well again. $4850 bill hurt huge! Relieved for 1 year warranty.
Date: August 30, 2024
Website: Google
Darren and crew did an...
Gord Beilner
Darren and crew did an excellent job. Very informative and respectful of our concerns. We will not hesitate to recommend their services to others. Job well done.
Date: August 30, 2024
Website: Google
Excellent service and very thorough....
Lisa LoStracco
Excellent service and very thorough. Great job! Cory and Casey absolutely awesome to work with!
Date: August 30, 2024
Website: Google
Giving a 4 for their...
Dazzler
Giving a 4 for their pleasant service. Nice people to deal with. Was surprised with an appointment it took 9 days to get my car back with 14 hours labour noted, but runs well so happy I'm running well again. $4850 bill hurt huge! Relieved for 1 year warranty.
Date: August 30, 2024
Website: Google
Featured Services
Transmission Repair

The evolution of transmissions has made these machines and systems increasingly complex. When transmission repairs are required, determining the cause and cure for what ails can be tricky.

Read More
Transmission Technology

At Mister Transmission we have access to leading-edge diagnostic equipment, enabling us to offer you the fastest and most accurate findings about what’s going on inside your vehicle’s transmission.

Read More
Transmission Maintenance & Service

Just as you have other parts of your car serviced, your transmission needs maintenance to ensure a long life and avoid transmission problems.

Read More
Mister Transmission Blogs
Recent Blogs
The Lifespan Of A Repaired Transmission
Maintaining the health of your vehicle's transmission is crucial for its overall
Read More
August 28, 2024
Why Transmission Repairs Can Be Expensiv...
Transmission repairs are one of the most significant automotive expenses a vehicle
Read More
August 21, 2024
Can Driving With A Bad Transmission Dama...
Driving with a malfunctioning transmission can cause serious damage to your vehicle.
Read More
August 14, 2024
The Costs Of Transmission Repairs: What ...
Transmission repairs can be a significant financial burden for car owners.
Read More
August 9, 2024
Should You Repair Or Replace Your Transm...
When faced with transmission problems, many car owners grapple with the decision of
Read More
July 31, 2024
How Long Does A Transmission Repair Take...
Transmission repair is a critical aspect of vehicle maintenance that ensures your car
Read More
July 23, 2024
Common Signs Of Transmission Trouble
Transmission problems can cause significant issues if left unaddressed, leading to
Read More
July 15, 2024
Is It Worth Fixing A Bad Transmission? A...
When your vehicle's transmission starts showing signs of trouble, it can be a
Read More
July 5, 2024
Why Your Transmission Shop Choice Matter...
In the ever-evolving automotive landscape of 2024, selecting the right transmission
Read More
June 28, 2024
Transmission Repair Vs. Replacement: Mak...
Understanding the condition of your vehicle's transmission is pivotal for its
Read More
June 21, 2024