Myths About Stick Shifters

By Mister Transmission

Manual transmissions are still a popular choice today as they do offer many benefits. Here we challenge some stick shift myths which are based on outdated information.

Though most new vehicles sold today come with automatic transmissions, there are people who tout stick-shift manual transmissions as being a much better option. However, some of the benefits they cite are actually stick-shift myths and are based on outdated information.

To help set the record straight, below are five common stick-shift myths, along with the truth behind each.

Myth #1: Stick shifts always get better fuel economy.

In the past it was pretty much a given that vehicles with manual transmissions would be more fuel-efficient than their automatic counterparts, but advancements in automatic transmission technology have closed that gap. It’s true that some vehicles get better mileage with a manual transmission, but the difference is usually quite small. In some of today’s models, the automatic transmission is becoming more advanced and gaining additional gears, so they are often now overtaking manuals in terms of fuel economy.

Myth #2: Stick shifts are always cheaper to buy.

Again, this is only true part of the time. In some cases, the manual version of a car will indeed cost less. But the current trend is toward pricing both manual and automatic versions of a car exactly the same.
Furthermore, you can’t always get the car you want with a manual transmission.

Myth #3: Stick shifts save on repair costs.

It’s true that replacing a manual transmission is usually cheaper than replacing an automatic. However, many automatic transmissions will never need to be replaced. With a stick shift, you’re likely to replace the clutch at least once or twice over the life of the car, which means your long-term maintenance costs may be higher.

Myth #4: Myth #4:Stick shifts are a must for sports cars.

Though manual transmissions are more common on sports cars, there will also often be the option of getting an automatic. And it’s becoming more common for some sports models to only come with automatic transmissions or to be equipped with clutchless paddle shifters.

Myth #5: Stick shifts work better for towing or other heavy-duty work. 

Actually, one could argue that stick shifts are worse for hauling loads. The increased weight increases the amount of wear on the clutch, whereas an automatic has no clutch to wear out. And the automatic transmissions on many full-size trucks or SUVs come with a towing package that can better handle the loads.

Stick Shift Realities:

When the argument in favor of the stick shift is based on how much fun it is, it’s undeniable. Stick-shift savvy also comes in handy if you’re a passenger in a manual-transmission car and the driver is incapacitated in some way. And it’s helpful if you’re stuck somewhere and the only car available is one with a stick.

Want to know more?
Visit of our locations

image-reviews image-reviews
Customer Reviews
Vehicle towed to mister transmission,...
Robert Carrier
Vehicle towed to mister transmission, he found the problem immediately. Being atraveler he drove me to a motel and started on my car. Returned my car the next day and also corrected another problem I had, that I was unaware of. I highly recommend this place to everybody his expertise and quick service, also his concern for the safety of his customers.
Date: May 31, 2025
Website: Google
Gary was super helpful! Got...
Denisha Bracey
Gary was super helpful! Got my VW Beetle in very fast and had it fixed just 2 days later! Car drives beautifully, price was fair, and I’m very happy!
Date: May 31, 2025
Website: Google
I highly recommend this shop!!!...
Mohit Mohit
I highly recommend this shop!!! A+ Service!! Thank you again Travis!! You are the best!!
Date: May 31, 2025
Website: Google
The team at Mister Transmission...
James Calpas
The team at Mister Transmission were friendly, approachable and competent. The rear differential on my Ram 1500 Outdoorsman was shot and these guys rebuilt and upgraded the rear differential at a reasonable cost. It runs great, solid as a tank!
Date: May 30, 2025
Website: Google
Replaced a rear differential for...
Glenn Alloway
Replaced a rear differential for one third the price of the dealership. Work was completed in 2 days.
Date: May 30, 2025
Website: Google
I have taken all my...
Soo Chung
I have taken all my vehicles here for transmission and axle repairs and service for several years now. The staff are pleasant to deal with and they have always delivered what they promise. Had a small issue with my truck and they were very accommodating. Got me in and on the road quickly. I would give 4.5 stars and recommend Mr Transmission for any transmission repairs or service.
Date: May 30, 2025
Website: Google
What an amazing team. Chris,...
Tammy Spears
What an amazing team. Chris, Ron and the other wonderful man. My car broke down this afternoon at a gas station but before it broke down the battery warning light kept coming on so I got a boost and drove my car to buy a battery. Well started to drive my car and the battery warning light came on again so I heard that Mr transmission does free car diagnostics so decided to call them and had an appointment for 1: 00. Well I just drove my car straight down there and parked my car in their parking lot because I knew as soon as I shut my car off it won't start. Well these three guys come straight to my car as it was squealing as well. They did their diagnostic and it turned out it was my alternator. Well these guys went out of their way to fix my car on the spot. They only work on transmissions but Chris thought I needed a break and fix my car on the spot. I had the parts delivered and the guys worked on it for hours but only charged me under an hour's labor. Their garage closes at 5:00 but all three of these wonderful men stayed later until my car was running properly. There are no words to express the gratitude I have for these three men. Not too many places go out of their way at their own cost to help someone get back on the road. Finding a garage that's willing to help out in a pinch, especially with something outside their usual scope of work, and then stay late to make sure you're back on the road safely, is incredibly rare and special.
Date: May 29, 2025
Website: Google
one of the best service...
Scott
one of the best service centers you will ever go to, quality work at a fare price.
Date: May 29, 2025
Website: Google
Sanjay and Bailey (technician) are...
Joy Hickox
Sanjay and Bailey (technician) are both amazing individuals to deal with.The customer service received from Sanjay is top notch and the knowledge and expertise and honesty from Bailey is incredible!I took my vehicle in there for a second opinion after already being to a different Mr. Transmission location for a diagnostic.Needless to say the outcome I received was the exact same from another location; being that there was absolutely nothing wrong with my CVT transmission (2018 Honda CRV) after being charged $180 and told that my transmission was the issue from my regular mechanic shop a couple days prior.I highly recommend Mr. Transmission (Exeter Rd location) 1000% to anyone and everyone who may be experiencing or believe to be experiencing transmission issues.Their knowledge, customer service, honesty, transparency, and expertise is amazing!Thanks so so so much guys for making my day great and leaving with a huge smile.
Date: May 29, 2025
Website: Google
Best place to take your...
Mekhi Dickson
Best place to take your vehicle. Kris is super honest and a great guy overall. I will definitely be back
Date: May 29, 2025
Website: Google
Featured Services
Transmission Repair

The evolution of transmissions has made these machines and systems increasingly complex. When transmission repairs are required, determining the cause and cure for what ails can be tricky.

Read More
Transmission Technology

At Mister Transmission we have access to leading-edge diagnostic equipment, enabling us to offer you the fastest and most accurate findings about what’s going on inside your vehicle’s transmission.

Read More
Transmission Maintenance & Service

Just as you have other parts of your car serviced, your transmission needs maintenance to ensure a long life and avoid transmission problems.

Read More
Mister Transmission Blogs
Recent Blogs
Why Is My Car Not Shifting Gears Properl...
Have you noticed your car struggling to shift gears? Whether it hesitates, jerks, or
Read More
May 23, 2025
What Happens When Transmission Fluid Is ...
Transmission fluid plays a critical role in keeping a vehicle’s transmission system
Read More
May 15, 2025
Used Transmission Vs. Rebuilt Transmissi...
Choosing between a used transmission and a rebuilt transmission is an important
Read More
May 7, 2025
Preventative Transmission Maintenance: 5...
A vehicle's transmission is one of its most critical components, responsible for
Read More
April 30, 2025
Transmission Rebuild Vs. Replacement: Wh...
When a vehicle's transmission begins to fail, owners often face a crucial decision:
Read More
April 23, 2025
Transmission Overheating Causes: How To ...
Transmission overheating occurs when the system becomes too hot to function properly.
Read More
April 16, 2025
Signs Of A Failing Transmission Filter A...
The transmission filter plays a crucial role in keeping the transmission system clean
Read More
April 7, 2025
Manual Vs. Automatic Transmission Mainte...
Your vehicle’s transmission plays a crucial role in keeping your car running
Read More
March 31, 2025
Honda Transmission Replacement Price: Wh...
The cost of replacing a Honda transmission varies depending on the model, year, and
Read More
March 28, 2025
How Much Does A New Transmission Cost? A...
A vehicle’s transmission is one of its most crucial components, responsible for
Read More
March 24, 2025